Papa Kelsey's Menu

Papa Kelsey's in Twin Falls, ID, is a beloved spot known for its generous portions and fresh, flavorful offerings. The menu shines with classics like the Italian Combo Sub, praised for its perfectly baked bread—crispy on the outside, soft inside—and fresh dough aroma that welcomes you from the door. Fans rave about the Southwest Chipotle Chicken Salad and the Papa Kelsey's Special with a healthy cauliflower crust, offering tasty variety beyond traditional subs. Don't miss the massive cinnamon rolls, a sweet finish that leaves a lasting impression. Sides like Parmesan Sticks and Garlic Cheese Bread, paired with house-made marinara or tangy raspberry vinaigrette, complement every meal. Customer reviews highlight the warm service and nostalgic charm, with longtime patrons recalling fond memories tied to signature subs like the pizza sub. Papa Kelsey's expertly blends hearty sandwiches, fresh salads, and comforting sides, making it a must-visit for anyone craving honest, satisfying American fare with a touch of homestyle warmth.