Papa Kelsey's

Located in the heart of Twin Falls, Idaho, Papa Kelsey's is a beloved local restaurant renowned for its hearty and flavorful sandwiches that cater to a variety of tastes. Specializing in fresh, made-to-order subs and salads, this eatery offers an inviting dining atmosphere where the warm aroma of freshly baked bread greets you as you walk in, instantly stirring your appetite.

Papa Kelsey's menu is a testament to the art of classic sandwich making, featuring standout options like the Italian Combo Sub, bursting with layers of savory meats and melted cheeses, and the Southwest Chipotle Chicken Salad, which perfectly balances smoky and tangy flavors with crisp greens. For those seeking lighter or vegetarian choices, the Veggie Sub is a colorful medley of black olives, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and melty mozzarella cheese, delivering a satisfying crunch and freshness in every bite.

One of the restaurant’s signature delights is the Papa Kelsey’s Special made with a cauliflower crust, a clever twist that keeps the indulgence balanced and appealing for health-conscious diners. Additionally, the Cuban Sandwich and Steak & Everything Sub are crowd favorites, boasting generous portions of savory steak, mushrooms, peppers, and the perfect combination of mozzarella with Swiss cheese melted to perfection.

Don’t miss the chance to indulge in Papa Kelsey’s desserts—especially their enormous, gooey cinnamon rolls that have developed a near-cult following, praised for their size and rich flavor. Pair this sweet treat with a cup of coffee, and you’ll find yourself savoring every bite as much as the friendly conversation often shared with the welcoming staff. Customer reviews highlight the consistently attentive service and genuine warmth of the owner, making each visit feel personal and memorable.

The kid’s menu offers hearty, well-portioned meals that ensure even the youngest diners leave satisfied. And while some guests note that pricing leans slightly on the upper side, most agree that the quality of ingredients, generous portion sizes, and friendly atmosphere more than justify the investment.

Whether you are a longtime local or just passing through Twin Falls, Papa Kelsey's promises an authentic and comforting dining experience where the simple joy of a perfectly crafted sub or salad is elevated by gracious service and genuine care. From the fresh dough rising in the oven to the careful assembly of each sandwich, this spot truly celebrates the art of satisfying, wholesome meals that keep customers coming back for over three decades.